Glock 17 or Sig P226?

Discussion in 'Rifle Opinions' started by Anonymous, Jan 2, 2005.

  1. Anonymous

    Anonymous Guest

    Glock 17 or Sig P226? Please state your opinion and why you chose that particular pistol.
     
  2. Anonymous

    Anonymous Guest

    This has nothing to do with RIFLE opinions. Go to shotgunworld.com, go to forums, and go to Off Topic. It's an honest mistake.
     

  3. 8pointduck

    8pointduck Super Member

    1,137
    0
    0
    Don't go to SGW , you can go to it right here on this sight . I can say they would be both worth getting , it all depends which one feels good in your hand and you can shoot better.
     
  4. huntswithdogs

    huntswithdogs Moderator

    1,287
    0
    0
    I've shot the Glocks and the S&W clones and don't like them because of the triggers. I haven't had the privilege of shooting the Sig. My wife has one of S&W99-45's.It took me about 4 trips to the range and about 500 rounds to get used to it. The long trigger pull will cause ya to shoot low( at least it did me).
    Give me a 1911 or single action revolver with a good smooth trigger any day,please.

    HWD
     
  5. TXVAshooter

    TXVAshooter Guest

    258
    0
    0
    Guest,

    Nothing wrong with posting here. Can't say as to the handgun, but others have good opines here on it.

    TXVA
     
  6. wwb

    wwb Super Member

    918
    0
    0
    Just my personal opinion, but if you want an autoloading handgun, get a 1911. I've tried DA and DAO autoloaders, and you can put 'em where the sun don't shine.

    My preference? A Ruger SA or an older S&W DA wheelgun; a 4" Model 19-3, pinned and recessed, with a target trigger and hammer is a particular favorite.

    I'm worried about that HWD guy.... we seem to agree on an awful lot of stuff.
     
  7. huntswithdogs

    huntswithdogs Moderator

    1,287
    0
    0
    Hey WWB,

    Great minds think alike and so do ours! KINDA SCARY!!

    Really though, I like the simpler things in life. I also don't take to changing too well. The old tried and true stuff suits me just fine.Heck I've even got camo in the original TREEBARK that I still wear! A good 12 ga pump,a decent centerfire rifle/scope combo that I can find ammo for, a 22 LR rifle and a 1911 is all we REALLY need.

    Now,I tell my wife differently so I can occassionally buy something else. Of course when I DO buy something new,it's got a special use such being strictly for varmits , turkeys , deer , etc. I think she really knows but just acts like she don't.

    HWD
     
  8. Anonymous

    Anonymous Guest

    My vote goes for the Sig.
     
  9. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    I own a glock 19 which is real close to the 17 and I own a glock 21 45 acp.The action is a bit looser on the glock and tighter on the sig.The glock WILL shoot all the time and has decent accuracy out of the box.The sig is a well machined weapon,great fit and finish.The FBI used to use sig exclusively,but now uses a 1911 springfield.The sig 226 I shot at the indoor range I go to and rent guns,shot well but the owner says the sig requires more cleaning and care than the glocks,and the one I shot was only slightly more accurate with hardball ammo,the glock shot 3 inch groups with anything I brought,no malfunctions,the sig had 2 fail to feed properly but was well used and needed cleaning.Thats my experience with both guns.Drop-Shot
     
  10. Anonymous

    Anonymous Guest

    Neither because they won't say .45 ACP on the frame. I had a Glock 17 range rental gun jam at the range on me. They are semiautos and need to be cleaned no matter the make. I'm just a .45 guy. Also don't get caught up in the FBI,Navy Seal ,LAPD, advertising hype. It's BS. A single unit of these services might be using a certain type of handgun and you are led to believe they ALL do.

    SIG P220 .45 ACP

    BigBear
     
  11. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    Bigbear you should have taken a picture of a glock jamming,thats rare.When the state of Mississippi wanted to change fron revolvers to semi-autos.all manufactures came,glock dropped theres out of a helecopter at 100 ft,they picked up the gun and fired a full clip.They parked a 3 1/2 ton truck on one in the mud for over an hour,pulled it out of the mud,hosed it off and fired a full clip.They next put a model 17 in a bucket and filled it with mud,after lunch they rinsed it off and fired a full clip.You had something very rare,30,000 rounds in the course of 3 days with 2 different glocks all abused and none failed to fire.Glock prmised that if we ever have a glock to fail to shoot for any reason,they wanted it back at the factory.You need to contact customer service,Glock Inc.PO Box369,Smyrna,Ga.30081 Thats why 94 % of Police and Sherriff departments all use glocks.I own 2 and have never had a malfunction.Go online and they will ask to have the pistol returned.They are supposed to shoot no matter what,dirty,hollowpoint.cheap ammo all should feed and those that don't need to be sent back.Drop-Shot
     
  12. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    I forgot to add bigbear that sig was there,police reps sherriff reps state Police reps,game warde reps and all shot the bill wilson 1911,ed brown 1911,sid 220 and 226,some wanted 9mm and some wanted 45 acp.Colt and Smith&Wesson was there,Ruger,Taurus and me.I shot till I was tired of holding a gun.So why was the glock chosen over all the others?I personally liked the bill wilson 1911 45 acp but it was no more accurate than the glock in the right hands,the Smith&Wesson and Ruger was very picky about what they shot.All chose the glock hands down cause it never failed.A springfield broke after 800 rounds,and thats what the fbi uses now.I like glock and you can tell.Company glock shooters shot under 2 inches with winchester silver tips,and remington golden sabres.speer gold dot went about 3 inches at 25 yards,thats 75 feet and I can't do that but I always hit well.I like the sig but I don't think it's a better gun just a different gun and I like to have a large choice to choose from.Drop-Shot
     
  13. Anonymous

    Anonymous Guest

    Drop shot ...I can tell you're enthusiastic about the Glocks.That's great. I've shot Glocks in .45,.40,9 mm and .357 sig. Never had a problem except that range rental. All were friends and they clean em as you should. I'll take a Glock any day over nothing. Keep your Glocks clean bro !!!

    http://www.thegunzone.com/glock/glock-kb-faq.html

    BigBear
     
  14. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    Thanks bigbear and before I die I want to own a hk 45.sig45,springfield 45,Kimber 45and a para ordance 45.My dad used to say when you want to start a fight use a 9mm but when your ready for it to finiish,grab a 45.Drop-Shot
     
  15. wired

    wired Guest

    681
    0
    0
    Which one to go with? Whichever one fits your hand better. I personally hate Glocks. I do agree that they're tough little buggers, but they feel like sh!t in my hand, and I hate the safety system. I've shot several Sigs, and I love them. Had I not gone for my Beretta 96, I would have gone with a Sig in .40 or .45 (I'll never own a 9mm). The Sigs feel great in my hand, and I like the fact that it's got an external safety. I've never seen a Sig jam, and the only time I've ever seen a Beretta jam was a guy limp-wristing the thing with Wolf 9mm ammo. I have heard stories of Berettas jamming in the middle east, but it had more to do with the magazine having sand problems than the actual pistol (also, Uncle Sam was providing them with crappy magazines, and the soldiers were writing home to get factory mags, which are awesome).

    Whatever you get, you'll still need to clean it. Don't listen to the whole "don't need to clean a Glock" crap. It's a pistol, it'll get dirty. You paid good money for it, take care of it. Just go to the gun shop and handle everything that looks good to you. Whatever feels best in your hand is what you should get.
     
  16. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    wired I never said you never have to clean a glock,I just said you don't have to as often as a closely fit firearm like the sig.I hav probely shot more handguns than 90% of the people on this forum,you name it I shot it and not just once.My job with the Mississippi state patrolemans was to shoot all guns till they misfired,all did at some point in time but the glock.Sounds like you don't own any of the cheap old plastic handguns.Before calling me a liar again go down to your local gun store rent a new glock of any caliber and bring a case of the cheapest junk you can find,45 or 9mm plan on spending the day and leaving dissapointed.Drop-Shot
     
  17. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    Wired by the way I have family in Mo and visit every year,we can meet and lay this problem to rest.I most likely own more handguns than you have ever shot and calling me a liar don't sit well with me.Drop-Shot
     
  18. wired

    wired Guest

    681
    0
    0
    Count to ten, bro. Breathe in, breathe out. I was never calling you a liar. It's just the typical thing I hear from most Glock fanatics is that you "never have to clean them". Granted, you could probably fire Glocks a lot more before you'd have to clean them than you would a Sig. I'm not doubting that at all. That's one of the reasons the old 1911's were popular (the ones that rattled like they were gonna fall apart). Loose tolerances and all. And no, I don't own any cheap plastic firearms *coughhipointcough* :D .
     
  19. Drop-Shot

    Drop-Shot Super Member

    3,764
    1
    38
    wired I don't call myself a glock fanatic,I'm a 911 nut.But my eyes were opened by what I witnessed,not heard,not read about.I was assigned the 21 45 acp and I shot 2 1/2 cases before lunch and 2 1/2 casses before break,the reps left after 3 days,bill wilson took his with him,most accurate but dirt in action made it have a slide malfunction.I went in this a smith&wesson fan and came out a glock fan,not because they are strickingly beautifull but if my life is on the line give me a glock.I just traded for an H&K expert,used but very little.I still like Smith&Wesson revolvers for good feel and workmanship.Glocks just work,abuse then don't clean them and they work ,not because I read it,not because someone said it.not because the advertised said it will,this man with all my heart saw it for 5 days straight.A pallet of 10mm,a pallat of 9mm a pallet of 45acp.We shot them all.the new colt did well but only the glock ate every thing and did not fail to shoot at any time.No cleaning for any gun.So I speak from experience not word of mouth.Drop-Shot
     
  20. wired

    wired Guest

    681
    0
    0
    We need a lot more of this online. There are a lot of 12 year olds that convince mommy to let them on the computer, and instantly become "experts" on everything from automotive design to life's troubles (I've seen an 17 year old that had the perfect girl that he was gonna be happy with for the rest of his life, and I've seen an 18 year old planning to construct an intake manifold from scratch in his garage). This is one of the reasons I don't take online arguements personally. Arguing online is like the Special Olympics - you may win, but you're still a retard. Experience can never be replaced by Google.

    Anyway, back to the subject at hand....

    Glock does make some reliable pieces of hardware, they just don't feel right in my hand and I simply prefer external safeties, so I most likely wouldn't have one in my collection. Most people would keep a quality sidearm nice and clean between relatively short shooting sessions, so any reliable piece would do the job just fine. If someone was comfortable with it, then by all means that would be an excellent choice for them.